The Year 7 voices in that 2015 Ofsted report remain among the most damning pieces of evidence about transition in English education, and the fact that the same patterns are still recognisable eleven years later suggests the problem is structural rather than accidental. The Montaillou example matters precisely because it demonstrates that intellectual ambition at KS3 is not aspirational rhetoric - it is a choice about what we believe young people are capable of, and the curriculum we hand them is the most honest answer to that question.
The Year 7 voices in that 2015 Ofsted report remain among the most damning pieces of evidence about transition in English education, and the fact that the same patterns are still recognisable eleven years later suggests the problem is structural rather than accidental. The Montaillou example matters precisely because it demonstrates that intellectual ambition at KS3 is not aspirational rhetoric - it is a choice about what we believe young people are capable of, and the curriculum we hand them is the most honest answer to that question.